Yes, in most cases this is exactly how it's supposed to work. A circuit breaker trips on overload or short circuit — too much current drawn on that specific circuit. A safety switch only trips on earth leakage (current escaping to earth, often through a person). An overload with no leakage to earth is a normal breaker-only trip, and the safety switch has nothing to detect.
See our RCD vs RCBO vs circuit breaker guide for the full breakdown of what each device actually does.
Blue Link Electrical Services is a NSW licensed electrical contractor (licence 332956C), working across Sydney since 2016. Call 0421 772 661 if it's happening repeatedly on the same circuit.
A breaker and a safety switch protect against two completely different things. A breaker trips when a circuit draws more current than it's rated for — too many appliances at once, or a dead short. None of that necessarily involves current leaking to earth, which is the only thing a safety switch watches for. So a clean overload trip on the breaker, with the safety switch staying on, is the system working correctly, not a fault in the safety switch.
We identify what's actually on that circuit, whether it's correctly rated for the load, and test for any underlying short circuit or degrading connection causing nuisance overloads — rather than just upgrading the breaker to a bigger one, which can mask a real problem instead of fixing it.
Not without checking why first — a bigger breaker can let a genuine wiring fault or overloaded circuit keep running past where it should have cut out, which is a real safety risk rather than a fix.
No — it means the trip wasn't an earth leakage event, which is the only thing the safety switch is designed to catch. Testing the safety switch's own test button confirms it's working independently.
Too many high-draw appliances running on one circuit at the same time — a kettle, toaster and heater all on one double power point, for example.
Possibly, especially if it trips instantly and repeatedly regardless of what's plugged in — that's worth a proper fault-finding visit rather than just resetting it.
Blue Link Electrical Services · NSW licence 332956C · since 2016 · fully insured · 24/7 emergency
Blue Link Electrical Services · 265 Illawarra Rd, Marrickville NSW 2204 · 0421 772 661 · bluelinkelectrical.com.au